|
Debra Lynn Dadd
Is This Wood Floor Renewal System Safe?QUESTION: Hello Debra:
Can you shed some light on the process and toxicity level for this 'new' wood renewal from NHance? The parent company is Chem Dry.
Thanking you in advance.
POSTED BY LINDA :: SOUTH CAROLINA USA :: 09/13/2006 4:22 PM DEBRA'S ANSWER:
The website didn't have much information on it, so I called the company and spoke to their training director and a chemist. Here's what I learned.
NHance is a wood renewal system that works on any type of finished wood. Most of their jobs are on wood floors and kitchen cabinets, but they can also do furniture, wood paneling, and the like.
If you were to have your floors, for example, refinshed in the standard way, they would sand off the old finish, creating a lot of dust, and apply a toxic oil-based finish. This would also take several days and more days to dry before you walk on it. Often people have to go stay in hotels because they can't walk on their floors.
NHance offers a completely different system.
First they clean the floors with their "odor-free" proprietary cleaner.
Then they etch the surface with water and an abrasive pad. This scratches up the surface so the new finish will adhere, without creating a lot of dust.
If there is any bare wood, they apply a wood dye "that has about the same amount of odor as water." Also, if you want to change the color of your floors, they can do that too.
And finally, they apply a coat of water-based polyurethane.
They described the entire process as "virtually odor-free" because what is odor-free to their noses may not be odor-free to a customer.
"Wait a minute," I said, "I've used water-based polyurethane and I wouldn't call it odor-free."
We agreed that their process, while perhaps not completely odor-free, is a vast improvment over standard practice. And they are in-and-out in one day. You can even get your floors renewed in the morning and stand on them in stocking feet in the evening.
I haven't seen in MSDS sheet for their water-based polyurethane. Personally, if I were to refinish my wood floors, I would probably use a water-based polyurethane. The advantage to this service that appeals to me is that they are using less-toxic products and I don't have to apply them myself.
I would love to hear from anyone who has had this product applied to find out what the levle of odor really is. They don't have this service in Florida yet.
Debra :-)
COMMENTS: I have multiple chemical sensitivities and have recently been testing a lot of products to choose the least toxic ones to use in a house I have been building. Not all water-based polyurethanes are alike. I found two to be extremely toxic to me, and one which is not, called Polyureseal BP by AFM.
I strongly suggest that you personally test any that you are considering using before putting it on your floor. What is toxic to me may not be to you, and vice versa. The way I do it is to have someone else apply the product to a piece of bare wood of the kind you will be putting it on, then let it dry for a few days. Put the finished wood into a glass jar with a tight metal lid. On a day when you feel good, open the jar, breathe in the fumes for one minute, and reclose the jar. Observe yourself for any symptoms (see Debra's immune system article for usual symptoms). After 4 days, if you haven't experienced any strong reactions, open the jar and inhale for 5 minutes. Observe yourself. After 4 more days, open the jar and inhale for 10 minutes. Observe yourself. If you have passed all of those tests, then sleep with the finished piece of wood near you on a piece of aluminum foil (to protect your sheets from contamination). If you still have no reaction, chances are excellent that you will tolerate the finish on your floor.
Molly POSTED BY MOLLY :: OREGON USA :: 10/11/2006 4:22 AM
I had NHance done on my kitchen floor and some of my cabinets when I was preparing my condo to sell. Any other type of refinishing was totally out of the question for me because of the dust, smell, and time.
I recommend it for the average sensitive person, but it might not be suitable for people with MCS.
There was a very small amount of dust and some odor, but nothing compared to the average home renovation project. The only dust came from where he used a brillo pad on my water-damaged cabinets. Of course, I opened the windows when he was there so the odor dissipated quickly. This generated far less odor than the low VOC paint my painter used.
You will not want to be in the house when they are doing it, but just keep the windows open and it's fine a couple of hours later. My husband said he didn't notice any smell at all.
Keep in mind that this isn't going to work miracles on your wood, and it won't last as long as traditional refinishing. I noticed some wear on my cabinets near the sink after only a few weeks. I moved out a couple of months after I had it done, so I have no idea how well the floor held up. POSTED BY CITIGIRL :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 11/24/2006 4:04 PM
Hi!
I saw your question and just wanted to let you know that I work for NHANCE and I'm amazed at the product!
I have severe allergies and asthma and was really worried about working around any type of chemicals...There are NO ODORS! Ive actually learned how to do the process of renewing cabinets and not only are the results remarkable, it is totally GREEN! I recommend using NHANCE wood renewal for anyone. POSTED BY NHANCE EMPLOYEE :: VIRGINIA USA :: 01/13/2009 3:32 AM :: POST YOUR COMMENT
Debra's List
~
100s of links
to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise
products
Debra's Free Newsletters
~
website
update, natural sweetener recipes, words of
wisdom
Debra's
Bookstore
~ recommended reading on health and the
environment
MCS
Recovery ~ resources for recovery
from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy
~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of
recipes)
Talk With
Debra
~
call for a personal consultation (fee)
Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.
|
|
|