Debra Lynn Dadd

Antimicrobal shoes for children

QUESTION:

I've noticed a few catalogs had been advertising antimicrobial shoes for children. Do you know anything about this? I have an uneasy feeling about the toxicity of whatever they're using to kill the mictrobes and I wonder about the effect of adding another disinfectant that might take out the "good germs" with the "bad germs"in the name of stink-free feet.

POSTED BY GAYLE :: ARIZONA USA :: 09/22/2006 4:28 AM


DEBRA'S ANSWER:

Advertising for antimicrobial shoes for both children and adults don't give much information on what the antimicrobial agent is, however, I did come across a couple of brand name antimicrobials mentioned, so I looked them up.

AgION is "a non-toxic, natural silver ion delivery system that inhibits reproduction, interrupts metabolism, and disrupts cell wall functions of many molds, yeasts, and bacteria. Silver...has been used for centuries as an antimicrobial agent...[bound together with other materials, it] acts as a delivery system that continuously releases silver ions, which suppress the growth of microbes...AgION has also been recognized by the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) as an acceptable food contact substance."

MicrobanŽ Antimicrobial doesn't say exactly what the antibacterial agent is, but they say on their website that it "has a long history of safe use" and that it is "built-in during the manufacturing process and will not wash off or wear away," which leads me to believe it may be silver also.

In response to the question, "Has anyone ever gotten sick from using products with MicrobanŽ antimicrobial protection?" they answer:


Extensive testing and a long use history have shown MicrobanŽ product protection to be safe. While it is impossible to say that no one will ever experience an allergic reaction to anything, it is highly unlikely a negative experience would be observed. Microban additives are used in very low levels measured in parts per million.

Given that these technologies are available, I would assume they are commonly used, and that an 'antimicrobial" shoe does not mean it's been sprayed with a toxic chemical.

I'm not aware of any negative health effects associated with skin exposure to silver, with the exception of a rare allergic reaction. I eat with silver-plated flatwear and wear silver jewelry next to my skin with no noticable ill effects, and any exposure one might have to silver in footwear would be much less than this.

As to whether they take out the "good germs" along with the "bad germs" I don't know. The little information that is given seem to indicate they kill ANY germ, but you can call these companies and ask all the questions you want.

I'm more concerned about the plastics used to make the shoes than the silver in the antimicrobial liner.

Debra :-)


COMMENTS:

With some European made shoes (think Sierra Trading Post clearence items), the anti bacterial is charcoal....I assume on the basis of keeping things dry so no germs can grow.

But...wasn't it nice in the "good old days" when shoes were made of leather and rubber and we knew to let them dry out at night....whatever moisture our socks didn't pick up. These days we spend 1/2 our time figuring out what labor saving things to avoid. I'm not really an irritable person....but it is kind of funny when one thinks of it.

POSTED BY JULIE :: IN USA :: 10/03/2006 4:20 PM


I know that Microban product is triclosan, which is a synthetic chemical that decomposes into products that are known to be quite toxic and persistent in the environment. Microban does a good job of hiding the composition of their product on their web site. Why? It's probably rated as being okay and safe, but many other chemicals have also had that safety net and have subsequently been found to be not so good for us. Silver has been used for centuries (acutally thousands of years), with no known ill-effects. So, as a mother & chemist, I will put my kids in the shoes from Lands End that use Agion's silver stuff.

POSTED BY GMYERS :: MA USA :: 08/06/2007 3:56 PM


Thanks so much for the information about the chemial shoes and for the information about the Land's End shoes.

POSTED BY GS :: ARIZONA USA :: 08/08/2007 12:14 PM


I can not tolerate Microban/triclosan in anything. It makes me very short of breath, with coughing, and causes me to have migraines, burning lungs, eyes and mucus membranes. I found this out the hard way. I've had to throw away or return products, such as my husbands underwear, air cleaners and dehumifiers with Microban in the filters. Triclosan is found in some hand sanitizers, dishwashing liquids and a lot of other products. Even toothpaste and toothbrushes can contain it, and my husband saw that it is in some new kitchen sinks, on the market. It is used in a lot of different products. That is a substance that is suspected of contributing to antibiotic resistant infections. It is not safe for some of us, despite what the company says.

POSTED BY DONNIE :: MICHIGAN USA :: 08/08/2007 12:16 PM


Aloha from Hawaii, After buying a pair of top of the line Teva slippers (flip flops) with Microban it felt strange when I wore them once. So I did a little phoning to Teva and on line searching and found out that Microban seems to be a by-product of the chemicals like Round Up. The parent groups on line talk about it in toys and I remember my child getting gift of a toy years ago with it in the doll and we got rid of it then and there as it seemed toxic. I will avoid it and tell people to do so, the web has alot of info and I am calling out to you to do your homework!!!!!

POSTED BY JO-ANNE EUPHEMIA :: HAWAII USA :: 08/16/2007 11:20 AM


Aloha from Hawaii, After buying a pair of top of the line Teva slippers(flip flops) with Microban it felt strange when I wore them once.So I did a little phoning to Teva and on line searching and found out that Microban seems to be a by-product of the chemicals like Round Up. The parent groups on line talk about it in toys and I remember my child getting gift of a toy years ago with it in the doll and we got rid of it then and there as it seemed toxic.I will avoid it and tell people to do so,the web has alot of info and I am calling out to you to do your homework!!!!!

POSTED BY JO-ANNE EUPHEMIA :: HAWAII USA :: 08/16/2007 11:20 AM


The chemical may inhibit the germs on the soles of shoes to reproduce but it does not stop the germ from remaining there, which makes the shoes mostly ineffective, and also some of those shoes basis is that it uses some type of material to keep the sole dry so it prohibits the growing of germs on damp areas, but viruses and bacteria are unlike protozoa and fungi, they don't need damp areas to grow. So be wise when choosing what shoe to buy. The FDA didn't take these things in consideration.

POSTED BY SINGH :: OHIO USA :: 09/30/2008 10:40 AM


:: POST YOUR COMMENT

Return to Q&A Blog

Debra's List ~ 100s of links to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise products
Debra's Free Newsletters ~ website update, natural sweetener recipes, words of wisdom
Debra's Bookstore ~ recommended reading on health and the environment
MCS Recovery ~ resources for recovery from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy ~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of recipes)
Talk With Debra ~ call for a personal consultation (fee)

Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.