Debra Lynn Dadd

Safe Silver Polish

QUESTION:

Like an idiot - YES, an idiot - I used some commercial silver cleaner last week that has got my lungs in a horrible mess. I've had a cough and really irritated lungs. Am going to the doctor this morning, and after reading about the ingredients last night, I'm really concerned. I'm hoping I get a doctor who knows what they're doing. This really confirms to me that this stuff is serious.

[another email] Before I went to the doctor, looked up the silver cleaner on the internet and got the ingredients. A 1% solution of the ingredients are toxic, and yet this one had 7%. Anyway, I took all that info with me to the doctor, and she basically acted like I was loony!! I left there with even less faith in the medical profession than before. I wouldn't have even gone to the doctor except that the article scared me. I got an inhaler and antibiotic and am improving, but I sure learned a valuable lesson.

J. P.

Is there a safe product or way to remove tarnish from silver? Thanks for your help.

K. S.
Massachusetts USA

POSTED BY K. S. :: MASSACHUSETTS USA :: 09/20/2005


DEBRA'S ANSWER:

The best thing to do is to not polish at all, but rather keep your silver wrapped in cotton "silvercloth". There are also boxes for storing silver flatware that accomplish the same purpose of preventing tarnish. If you can't find silvercloth at your local fabric or jewelry stores, you can order it online from Blanks Fabric, Specialty Supplies has a silvercloth-covered drawer insert that holds silverware, and Vermont Country Store silvercloth bags and fabric by-the-yard.

If your silver is tarnished and needs to be polished before you put it in the bags, there are a few commercial silver cleaners you could use.

Twinkle is often recommended as the least toxic silver cleaner. According to it's MSDS it contains 1-5% propylene glycol considered "less hazardous than other chemicals", but there is "no inhalation hazard" present. The rest is mostly clay, soap and water.

We've been using Wright's Silver Cream. According to their MSDS, the only hazardous ingredient is silicon dioxide, but this is only hazardous by dust inhalation, and there is no such exposure with this product. It has very little odor.

I also recently picked up a jar of Sunshine Products Professional Tarnish Remover Their main ingredients are diatomacious earth and glycerin. On the label it says "All natural, absolutely free from any injurious substance, child safe."

Here are more tips on cleaning and caring for silver from professionals:

Debra :-)


COMMENTS:

It's about the silver polish....

the best polishing tool ever is the ENJO silver polish fibre...without ANY chemical it removes tarnish and makes the silver shine. I can hardly believe I ever used that super-toxic stuff...bad for us, bad for the world.

POSTED BY RJ11 :: ONTARIO CANADA :: 10/05/2006 9:38 AM


Debra, I can't believe you didn't mention your own "recipe" for cleaning silver, found in your books!

I use the combination of aluminum foil and baking soda, and find it works great for lightly tarnished, immersible silver items.

POSTED BY MICHELLE :: ONTARIO CANADA :: 10/11/2006 3:44 AM


Silver Soak

This is a clean, low-cost alternative to chemical silver cleaners. All you do is soak your silver items in this solution until they are clean.

4 cups very warm water
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
2 sheets of aluminum foil

Place one piece of aluminum on the bottom of a glass 9 x 10 baking dish. Combine the water, baking soda and salt and pour into dish. Place the silver in the dish and cover with the other piece of aluminum. Make sure that the silver is submerged in the solution.

Allow the silver to sit for 5 minutes. You will see the tarnish disappear from the items and move to the foil. Rinse well. It even removes the tarnish from tiny nooks and crannies!!

Keep replacing the foil as needed when they turn black.

POSTED BY MARTHA MATTHEWS :: CHRISTIAN-HOMEMAKING.COM :: WWW.CHRISTIAN-HOMEMAKING.COM :: CA USA :: 10/11/2006 3:54 AM


I use plain white toothpaste to clean my silver. (The old type of toothpaste- not the gels or whitening formulas just the plain white toothpaste. I think the box says "regular paste". It does have a scent to it so I just open the windows when using it and it hasn't bothered me.

POSTED BY DHINES :: KENTUCKY USA :: 10/11/2006 9:30 AM


I just purchased an antique set of flatware than is silver plated. How do I remove the tarnish without eating through the silver plate? Thank you so much for any input you can provide.

COMMENT FROM DEBRA: Use any of the methods mentioned above.

POSTED BY PAM :: TEXAS USA :: 11/04/2008 6:16 PM


I am an Executive Chef and I have tried every method and, yes, most cleaners are toxic. We have used Silvermate liquid silver cleaner for 15 years at our Grand Hyatt and it is mild enough to use your bare hands in it and it only takes a few seconds to clean and polish a piece of silver without any scrubbing. i hope this helps. Chef M.

COMMENT FROM DEBRA: I took a look at their website at www.silvermatecompany.com and the product looks pretty good. Thanks for recommending it and giving your personal experience with it.

POSTED BY CHEF M. :: DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA USA :: 03/12/2009 4:48 PM


Some where I saw an article that said use baking soda. I tried it on two heavily tarnished spoons. Works, a little slowly and with a bit of elbow grease...but most of us need the exercise. I got most of it off the first time around....will do a little more next time I wash dishes.

My mother had silverplate silverware and used it all the time and it didn't tarnish....I think we just always used it and it stayed OK. I am switching from stainless to silverplate for health reasons and think I will just get enough out of the box to keep it all being regularily used and see if I have as much luck as may mother and grandmother had.

POSTED BY JULIE :: INDIANA USA :: 03/22/2009 7:58 PM


Any non-toxic toothpaste (paste - not gel) will work.

I use a toothbrush slightly moistened with water and some toothpaste and scrub the silver with that. Or one can use a cloth with water and toothpaste.
it works like magic (beware commercial toothpaste which is pretty nasty - I use only the safer kinds).

Rinse with water or safe soap and water afterwards.

This is a great use for when you get to the end of a tube of toothpaste - simply cut it open and rub cloth or brush in the leftovers and polish your silver with it!

POSTED BY LIBERTY :: MOVING BEYOND MCS :: MOVINGBEYONDMCS.BLOGSPOT.COM/ :: OHIO CANADA :: 03/22/2009 8:05 PM


:: POST YOUR COMMENT

Return to Q&A Blog

Debra's List ~ 100s of links to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise products
Debra's Free Newsletters ~ website update, natural sweetener recipes, words of wisdom
Debra's Bookstore ~ recommended reading on health and the environment
MCS Recovery ~ resources for recovery from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy ~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of recipes)
Talk With Debra ~ call for a personal consultation (fee)

Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.