Debra Lynn Dadd

Space Heater Recommendations?

QUESTION:

Dear Debra,

I love your newsletter.

Do you have any recommendations for space heaters?

I've tried numerous kinds and models, and they all make me sick either immediately after they've been on for a while. I've borrowed some Intertherms and cannot tolerate them.

I had to have a faulty gas heater disconnected, and the wiring in this mobile is not
adequate for an electric whole house heater, so I'm stuck with space heaters.

Luckily I'm a warm climate, but there are some cold nights coming up next month.

Also, I do well at night under lots of blankets, except my nose which sticks out gets frozen. Any ideas?

Frosty in Tucson

POSTED BY MR :: ARIZONA USA :: 10/03/2006 11:43 PM


DEBRA'S ANSWER:

I have a similar situation to yours, where I live in a warm climate with some frosty nights in the middle of winter. They are so rare we don't even have central heat (only central air conditioning) so I rely on space heaters.

I've never used Intertherms, but I've heard that people do react to the paint as it outgasses when the heater is heated. I don't know how used the Intertherms were that you tried, but they may be fine if they are just more "baked".

I have had success with the DeLonghi oil-filled radiator type heaters. These too are painted and smell at first. I gave one to a friend to use for a winter and after that it had no odor at all and we were able to use it in our house.

The heaters I like best are the little square ceramic heaters. They cost about $40 and are a cube of about six inches. They are usually not painted and I can use them right out of the box. You can get them at almost any hardware or home improvement store.

I'd like to hear which heaters others have used successfully.

Debra :-)


COMMENTS:

Hi..this is a question instead of a comment, do you have a brand name of the heaters you are talking about? Sandy

COMMENT FROM DEBRA: There are many brand names for ceramic heaters. The one I have is made by Rival. Just type "ceramic space heater" into your favorite search engine to find them. I would suggest, though, that you purchase one at a local store so you can see that the housing is metal and what type of finish it might have.

POSTED BY SVW :: WASHINGTON USA :: 10/05/2006 9:30 AM


after trying a lot of different space heaters, i find the ceramic ones work the best as well w/little or no off-gassing symptoms (the one i bought is a holmes). we (my husband and i) have a couple of delonghis at another property that still off-gas terribly after two winters (the older variety was not as toxic - they must be using a different paint), so we only use them as an emergency backup, and then only for short periods.

the reason i'm now using the ceramic space heaters may help someone sort out heat-related symptoms of a different sort. i moved to an apt. in december (colorado) that has older (50 yr) baseboard hot water/oil heat (copper pipe and flange units). thought cool, this should be great - no carbon monoxide, no contaminated ducting, no blowing particulants around in the air.

after several weeks of my cat throwing up and me having all kinds of bad juju symptoms (stomach bloating, dry eyes, chest pain, wheezing, sore throat, bleeding gums, leg cramps, etc.), which seemed related to a chemical sweet smell in the air, i tracked down the culprit to these baseboard units (sweet smell/symptoms stronger on colder days, of course). i thought the copper pipes were just filled w/water, but they also contain glycol (gotta love the internet), hence the chemical sweet smell (which would occur only if there is leakage). my symptoms map to low-level glycol poisoning, since it is the airborne variety (much more serious if you drink the stuff) - there are most likely pinhole leaks in the pipes or in the packing material around the joints (i bellied up to the hvac bar to learn this stuff). the hotter i run the system and the longer, the stronger the odor and the worse the symptoms (cat will actually try hiding in a closet or the bathtub or yowling, scratching at the front door).

cat's fine and all my symptoms are gone since i've turned off the system (they are easily repeatable, including the cat puking/hiding/yowling, if i turn the system back on for any length of time). the landlord thinks i'm crazy and won't pay to have the units checked for leaks. i may pay to have it checked myself, because i like the apt. a lot. everything else is squeaky-clean, air quality-wise (using my "cat" scan and my own symptoms as a check), new tight windows, etc. a very happy space with a very poisonous vintage heating system.

unfortunately, unlike with carbon monoxide leaks and gas leaks, there is no help via fire dept. or city utilities, health dept., etc. to check for leaks/levels of exposure with glycol or ordinances to force the landlord into fixing a glycol-infused boiler system.

POSTED BY SHE BLINDED ME WITH SCIENCE :: COLORADO AND WASHINGTON USA :: 02/18/2008 8:11 PM


We had to get rid of our DeLonghi oil filled heater. It had that sweet odor, too, that I assumed was either paint or some new plastic part out gassing. I'm also sensitive to ethylene glycol (antifreeze) that is in many products - printer ink, some synthetic rubber, some herbicides...

POSTED BY SVE :: WASHINGTON USA :: 09/30/2008 10:15 AM


i have been sick for 3 months now..real paranoid and nervous all the time.. just couldn't figure out why.. went to the ER and they couldn't find anyrthing but when got home, could smell oil..sure enough,unplugged the Delonghi heater for last 2 days and am finally feeling well.. like my old self again..don't know if there is a leak in it or what ..maybe just allegic to this thing but i am..using a conventional electric heater again..no more electric oil heaters for me..thought i was dying for the last 3 months..thank God I figured it out....

COMMENT FROM DEBRA: It is most likely the paint on the heater. I had the same problem, but after about a year of use, the smell finally burns off. I loaned it to a friend who was without a heater and she wasn't bothered by the odor.

POSTED BY RANDY NEWLAND :: OHIO USA :: 01/30/2009 2:44 PM


My home office was cold because of crushed duct. I tried our old electric oil heater but still can't manage the slight smell. Bought a parabolic heater after checking it out at Costco. But I returned it because a subtle high pitched electrical "sound" was giving me a headache; my husband couldn't hear it. I bought the same model, thinking first was defective, same sound, returned it. I'm probably electrically sensitive. Bought another space heater recommended by a friend with MCS but again felt the electricity in my head, took it back. Finally I went online looking for something safe for me. I ordered an Evergain far infrared Bio-energy heater, more expensive but uses only 400 watts, doesn't use up the oxygen in the room, and is totally silent, including in my head. The smell from the plastic offgassing seems to be leaving fairly quickly. Keep your fingers crossed for me.

Juliene

POSTED BY JULIENE :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 02/10/2009 5:05 AM


:: POST YOUR COMMENT

Return to Q&A Blog

Debra's List ~ 100s of links to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise products
Debra's Free Newsletters ~ website update, natural sweetener recipes, words of wisdom
Debra's Bookstore ~ recommended reading on health and the environment
MCS Recovery ~ resources for recovery from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy ~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of recipes)
Talk With Debra ~ call for a personal consultation (fee)

Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.