Debra Lynn Dadd

Good Air Filters?

QUESTION:

Anybody know about air purifiers for the home. Any special brand that is good? Thanks, Cathy

POSTED BY CATHY RUSSO :: CALIFORNIA USA :: 10/09/2006 7:45 AM


DEBRA'S ANSWER:

The brands I recommend are on the Air (Indoor) page of Debra's List.

I personally don't use a freestanding air filter. My recommendation has always been and continues to be not to use an air filter unless you cannot change the conditions in your home to reduce air pollutants. There are elements in fresh air which are lost when air is filtered. We do use central air conditioning six months of the year and have a high-efficiency particle filter in our central system.

Which filter is best for you really depends on whether you are wanting to remove gasses from toxic chemicals, or particles from the air. And also there is a whole list of features to consider, like noise level and variable speeds. A full list of factors to consider and how to choose an air filter is in my book Home Safe Home and Allergy Buyers Club has a great comparison chart of different brands they recommend.

But I would love to know which filters others are using and any comments you have on them. Readers?

Debra :-)


COMMENTS:

I personally went through the struggle of finding an air purifier that worked well and did what it says. There are so many out on the market and they all advertise something different, so as a consumer, it can be very confusing. We personally use and recommend the Healthmate by Austin Air. The reason is it is not only has a medical grade HEPA filter for the removal of over 99.97% of particulates (over .3 microns), but it also addressed the chemical, gases and odors so prevalent in homes today. Everyone worries about biological contaminants and these are important as they can be allergens and asthma triggers, but in addition, this unit removes over 3,000 chemicals, gases & odors through it's cabon/zeolite filtration blend. It is the chemical exposure we get on a daily basis that concerns me the most in today's indoor environments.
This product comes in differnt sizes and a variety of color choices and it is ALL manufactured in the US which is great in promoting our own economy!
Best of luck to you :)

POSTED BY LISA :: GREEN NEST :: WWW.GREENNEST.COM :: CA USA :: 10/10/2006 5:02 PM


We use an Aireox air filter in our bedroom--however do have our window open as much as possible--and have been very happy with it. We also have an Aireox air filter in our car. They both work great and I would recommend them both highly. The units are both metal and have not had problem with odor with them.

POSTED BY WENDY SAILOR :: WASHINGTON USA :: 10/10/2006 5:06 PM


My son has asthma as well as being an effective sponge for pretty much any virus which sets foot in North America. We live in an older home, and though we've done everything short of rebuilding it to minimise indoor air pollution, we do like to keep our windows open! To help him while he sleeps, we purchased a medical grade air purifier from intelligentair.com, after considerable research. They are reasonably priced for what you get... true HEPA, a large carbon filter, and UV. Filters last for at least a couple of years, so the hidden cost factor of filter replacements is nowhere near as shocking as most off-the shelf purifiers. It is incredible the improvement in his breathing since we've started using it.

POSTED BY SAGEDADDY :: WHITING DESIGN :: WWW.WHITINGDESIGN.CA :: ONTARIO CANADA :: 10/25/2006 6:13 PM


We are beginning the search for a good air filter to use indoors for a child with asthma triggered by air pollution and other chemical irritants that occasionally enter our home. This summer has been terrible with air pollution day after day. The winter can be bad sometimes with wood burning that some neighbors do for "special occasions". We'd like to run the air purifier on these bad days.

I began by going to Sharper Image and buying one of their units based on a coworker's recommendation and the fact a store was 30 minutes drive. My wife took it out of the box and immediately we both smelled a strong almost glue odor that is clearly part of the plastic casing. The stainless steel units have no odor but they are inside the plastic. Next, we read in the manual that there is a small but distinct hazard of "ozone" and people with asthma or sensitivities should ask their doctors about that.

Today I read a few things on this website and will see if I have Debra's book where she says she talks about these. I think we have earlier book, Debra.

Anyway, it makes sense to have metal housing, but my wife and I were wanting washable filters as we both independently over the years have heard of issues with bacterial contamination in "paper" type filter systems. I mean we have that in our vacuum cleaner, but I'm not happy about it in my child's room. Something I can wash, that I can deal with.

I haven't looked at the websites posted on Debra's list under indoor air quality yet, but in any event would appreciate more advice on washable filters and if they even make sense since we primarily need to filter out (at times of high outdoor air pollution in our neighborhood that trickles indoors eventually) chemicals much more than particulate matter.

Thank you.

COMMENT FROM DEBRA: It's my understanding that washable filters are for particles only and not for gasses. The websites I've listed under Air Filters on the Air page of Debra's List
are tried and true and have been used for years by people with MCS. They will reliably remove chemicals.

POSTED BY JULIEN :: NEW YORK USA :: 10/05/2007 12:10 PM


:: POST YOUR COMMENT

Return to Q&A Blog

Debra's List ~ 100s of links to 1000s of nontoxic, natural & earthwise products
Debra's Free Newsletters ~ website update, natural sweetener recipes, words of wisdom
Debra's Bookstore ~ recommended reading on health and the environment
MCS Recovery ~ resources for recovery from multiple chemical sensitivities
Sweet Savvy ~ how to choose and use natural sweetners (lots of recipes)
Talk With Debra ~ call for a personal consultation (fee)

Copyright ©2004-2007 Debra Lynn Dadd - all rights reserved.